Findlay and Hancock County are home to many spots to order a few pieces of pizza. From carry out or dine in, to vegan-friendly to wood-fired, to just traditional, really good pizza – there are plenty of places to choose from. See our full list here, and check out some suggestions below!
Joey Fratello’s has great pizza, calzones, and appetizers – making it a great choice for a big party!
Joey Fratello’s Pizzeria
116 E. Sandusky St., Downtown Findlay
419-427-5639
Joey Fratello’s is a Downtown Findlay staple – and for a reason! With delicious pizza and calzones you can’t go wrong with a Joey’s pizza. Dine in is available, as is carry out and delivery!
Jac & Do’s
635 N. Main St., Arlington; 419-365-6415
1905 Tiffin Ave., Findlay; 419-422-0070
1201 Trenton Ave., Findlay; 419-422-5778
Carry out, order delivery, or dine in at this Hancock County staple at one of their three locations. Choose to enjoy Jac & Do’s in Arlington, or on either side of Findlay, with a location on Tiffin Avenue, as well as on Trenton Avenue! Jac & Do’s features a traditional thin crust pizza and is a favorite of many Findlayites. The Jac & Do’s in Arlington is also open for breakfast!
Heavenly Pizza gives back to the community and offers Jumbo pizzas to feed a crowd!
Heavenly Pizza
1404 N. Main St., Findlay
419-423-7494
Heavenly Pizza offers great pizza and is prepared to feed a crowd with their Jumbo Size pizzas. What is even better than their pizza is their pay-it-forward program for children. Heavenly Pizza offers a slice of pizza and a bottle of water to any children after school and during lunch hours Friday and Saturday!
Paradise Pizza
542 Sixth St., Findlay; 419-422-9200
145 Main St., Benton Ridge; 419-859-9200
Order a traditional favorite or a fun specialty pizza (baked potato or bacon double cheeseburger anyone?) and for vegetarians the Garden Pizza loaded with mushrooms, onions, green peppers, banana peppers and tomato is a must have. Paradise has two locations, one in Findlay and the other in Benton Ridge!
Looking for a low-carb option? These crustless pizza bowls from Dougie Johns are the way to go!
Dougie Johns Pizza
106 S. Main St., Downtown Findlay
567-250-8978
Dougie Johns has grown a lot since they opened their doors less than two years ago. Dougie Johns offers plenty of pizza options – including dairy-free cheese, cauliflower crusts, and even a Keto-friendly crustless pizza bowl. Dougie Johns offers car-side pick-up and delivery, as well as dine-in options both inside and on their patio along Main Street.
West Main Crust
301 W. Main Cross, Downtown Findlay
419-423-4075
Located inside Great Scot on West Main Cross Street, West Main Crust may taste familiar to many Findlayites. West Main Crust pizzas are made using local legend Rocking U’s recipes! Don’t miss the specialty pizzas like the Pancho Villa and Cattle Baron!
Breadsticks or Pizza? How about both at Campus Pollyeyes!
Campus Pollyeyes
339 S. Blanchard St., Findlay
567-525-5539
Campus Pollyeyes fan will tell you – the pizza is great but the stuffed breadsticks make them famous. Breadsticks can be stuffed with pizza stuffings like pepperoni and cheese, or stuff them with roast beef or chicken.
Are you drooling yet? These are just a few options of the many pizza places in Findlay and Hancock County. See all the Pizza and Wing Restaurants here and find your favorite!
This post was originally published on May 19, 2019 and has been updated.